Skip to main content
News 13 Sep 2021 - 3 min read

Maccas in breach of Ad Standards ethics code for radio host post

By Sam Buckingham-Jones - Senior Writer
Andrew "Cosi" Costelli on instagram talking about maccas

A similar post on SAFM Adelaide's Instagram page. The post on Andrew "Cosi" Costello's person account has been removed.

More major brands are being stung by Ad Standards’ crackdown on influencers and content creators on social platforms. McDonald's has been found in breach of the Code of Ethics for a post by a radio host working at a station with which the fast-food chain had a partnership.

What you need to know:

  • McDonald's has been found to be in breach of the Code of Ethics after an Instagram post by a South Australian radio host.
  • Maccas had no relationship to the host individually, but its partnership with the radio station meant the post was deemed not clearly distinguishable advertising.
  • Maccas says it is disappointed with the ruling but the post has been removed.

McDonald's has been found to be in breach of Ad Standard’s code of ethics after a South Australian breakfast radio host shared an image of Maccas products gifted to the radio station on his personal Instagram account.

Bec, Cosi and Lehmo host a weekday breakfast program on SAFM, an Adelaide-based radio station. Andrew “Cosi” Costello also has a personal account, @southaussiewithcosi, with more than 100,000 followers.

On July 28, Costello shared an image of a man, a woman and two children in matching McDonalds-labelled pyjamas holding McDelivery bags. The caption read: "Verified @maccas_sa have been serving South Australians for 50 years. How cool is that? Tonight we are celebrating their birthday with delivery and my girls are wearing the @peteralexanderofficial limited edition maccas PJ’s.” Ad Standards received a complain that the post was sponsored by either Peter Alexander, the creator of the pyjamas, or McDonald's.

McDonald's said while it had a partnership with SAFM and had gifted the products as a gesture of goodwill, the talent’s own brand was never a part of the discussion.

“McDonald's does not have any commercial relationship with “South Aussie with Cosi” or the talent directly. As such the content… is entirely outside of McDonald’s reasonable control,” the fast food chain said.

Unlike previous posts Ad Standards has found to be in breach, McDonald's argued, this instance was not a clear-cut example of giving a free product with the expectation of a social media post.

The Ad Standards community panel was split over whether Mcdonald's had any influence over the creation of the Instagram post. The majority, however, felt the ongoing sponsorship of the radio station meant Costello was motivated to post about McDonald's.

“This constituted a sufficient degree of control over the Instagram post to satisfy this provision of the Code,” Ad Standards noted, finding the post to be in breach.

McDonald's said while it was disappointed with the finding, it “takes its responsibility as an advertiser seriously” and had asked for the post to be removed.

Ad Standards recently found Samsung in breach of the Code of Ethics for a post from an influencer that it had not paid for. It said it would contest the decision. 

Share your reaction (and see how others voted)

Leave a comment (you must be logged in)

Be the first to comment

Search Mi3 Articles

Make it personal

Join Mi3 to receive our weekly edition and personalise your experience