Skip to main content
News 17 Sep 2026  - 6 min read

Free TV’s streaming dilemma: Canberra weighs free-to-air overhaul as almost 30% watch broadcast but not BVOD; Adgile warns better targeting cannot replace reach

By Vihan Mathur - Journalist

The Albanese Government has put free TV’s delivery model up for review, warning against “unmanaged decline” as it proposes three options: Squeeze commercial broadcasts from three transmission multiplexes to two; put streaming first and terrestrial broadcasting in the backseat; or put aerial technology on steroids. But OzTAM’s figures expose the audience challenge: Almost 30 per cent of Australians, including 26.7 per cent of 16–39-year-olds, watch broadcast but not BVOD within a month. Adgile sees potential for stronger advertising returns online, but warns that better targeting cannot replace lost reach - and publisher optimisation may serve the publisher’s business before the advertiser’s. Behind the debate sits a conditional spectrum bargain: Commercial broadcasters will work towards UHF clearance in the early 2030s if their broadcasting tax is permanently scrapped, while mobile operators eye the frequencies for 6G.

Almost 30 per cent of Australians, including more than a quarter of 16-39-year-olds, watch broadcast television but not BVOD within a month, exposing the audience challenge facing a Government review of how free-to-air TV should be delivered.

OzTAM’s insight into viewing patterns comes as the Federal Government invites three potential futures for the sector in its new consultation paper, Technology Scenarios for Free-To-Air Television. Released on 15 September, as Australian television nears its 70th anniversary, the paper opens a debate spanning audience access, broadcaster costs, advertising effectiveness and mobile operators’ ambitions for future 6G services. The paper warns that “unmanaged decline” would erode free TV’s value, while exploring whether valuable spectrum could be released for other uses.

OzTAM’s VOZ Total TV Viewing Report for the first half of 2026 puts exclusive monthly broadcast penetration at almost 30 per cent of Australians, 26.7 per cent of people aged 16–39 and 32.6 per cent of men. “In other words, within the month, these viewers watched broadcast TV but did not watch BVOD,” OzTAM told Mi3.

Those viewers may still use other streaming services. The figures also describe current behaviour, rather than establishing how many would be unable or unwilling to migrate to broadcaster apps. They nevertheless identify an audience those apps are not currently reaching within the month.

The consultation document also puts BVOD’s share of total free-to-air viewing minutes at 19.1 per cent in the first half of 2026. While households increasingly use both broadcast and streaming, most viewing time still goes to broadcast.

OzTAM said examining potential viewer exclusion from reduced traditional transmission requires consideration of location, internet connectivity, demographics, “access to streaming services and socioeconomic circumstances, as well as age and people’s cultural and language background”.

The 3 ‘technology combinations’

The consultation paper maps out three potential scenarios, or “combinations” of how free TV could continued to be delivered. First, the “partial online” option stays close to today’s mix of aerial television and streaming but squeezes commercial broadcasters onto fewer shared transmission multiplexes, each carrying several TV channels. Commercial services would move from three multiplexes to two in each licence area, retaining the existing broadcast standard while using more efficient video compression. 

That would offer transmission savings, but require fewer broadcast channels in metropolitan and larger regional markets. Streaming apps would continue alongside broadcasting, while a satellite safety net would remain for viewers in remote areas or with inadequate aerial reception.

The “online-dominant” option puts streaming first, putting basic broadcasting on the back burner as “nightlight” service with one channel per broadcaster for viewers “unable or unwilling” to move online. Access to the wider offering would require suitable internet - a complete migration online is also canvassed as a variation.

The third option, “broadcast enhancement”, would put aerial TV infrastructure on steroids, upgrading transmission to the more efficient DVB-T2 standard to potentially improve channel choice and picture quality. The paper calls it a “significant and complex undertaking” that would require investment in new transmission infrastructure. Not to mention, some households would require compatible televisions or DVB-T2-capable receivers to keep watching broadcast services.

The industry should be asking why a technologically superior advertising environment isn’t consistently producing superior outcomes, rather than assuming the technology is the problem.

— Shaun Lohman, founder and managing director, Adgile

‘Better targeting is not the same thing as better advertising’ 

Adgile founder and managing director, Shaun Lohman argued the delivery platform does not determine whether broadcasters can attract mass audiences.

“Mass reach comes from content, accessibility and the ability to create shared cultural moments,” he told Mi3.

Sport plays a monumental role in that proposition, Lohman argued, with audiences already consuming major events through broadcaster platforms and local networks holding significant sporting rights into the next decade. He sees the fight for ad dollars only “intensifying” as global streamers continue to expand their advertising businesses.

“But, the ability of Australian broadcasters to compete with those global platforms will be influenced far more by whether we create a genuinely level regulatory playing field, and have the ability to enforce it, than by whether television arrives through radiofrequency spectrum or the internet,” he said. 

The bigger issue Adgile’s analysis points to isn’t streaming. “It’s how the advertising industry uses streaming.”

“There has been a huge amount of effort put into lifting linear TV planning conventions and dropping them into VOD. Unsurprisingly, that doesn’t always work,” said Lohman. 

Adgile data still shows linear delivering stronger outcomes for traditional TV advertisers, which he attributed to the industry’s greater proficiency in buying it. “The industry should be asking why a technologically superior advertising environment isn’t consistently producing superior outcomes, rather than assuming the technology is the problem.”

For Adgile head of insights, Stu Carr, a managed hybrid transition offers the strongest opportunity to improve free-to-air television’s advertising proposition. While not claiming expertise in the “precise transmission architecture”, Carr told Mi3 the transition should be judged from an advertiser’s perspective against three things: “Unduplicated audience reach, well-managed frequency and incremental business outcomes across broadcast and BVOD”.

Internet delivery could extend free TV to households and devices without an aerial, while improving flexibility, addressability and accountability. But Carr pointed to Government figures showing 20 per cent of Australian households still watch free TV only through traditional broadcast.

“Reducing broadcast too quickly could therefore exchange one reach gap for another. Mass reach is not guaranteed by either delivery method; it depends on maintaining broad audience access and coordinating delivery across both," he said. 

Carr said Adgile’s evidence was stronger on advertising effectiveness than on forecasting long-term audience reach. Research with the Video Futures Collective and WPP Media across $200 million in video investment found linear and streaming played different but complementary roles. Linear remained the principal scale driver, while streaming generated measured business outcomes about twice as efficiently within the activity analysed.

“The modelling therefore supported a rebalancing rather than a replacement of linear television, retaining linear as the foundation of the video plan while increasing investment in a diversified streaming mix to as much as 40 per cent,” Carr said.

In some categories, that diversification increased modelled business outcomes by up to 5 per cent. The findings concern the streaming mix analysed, rather than BVOD alone, and performance varied materially by platform, device, viewing context, creative and frequency.

“Broadcasters can therefore retain the scale benefits of linear while using streaming to extend and potentially improve advertising effectiveness, but not by treating every streaming impression as interchangeable or optimising around reach alone," said Carr. 

In addition, better targeting and measurement could offset some of the “economic impact” of lost broadcast reach, but could not replace the reach itself. “Addressability should extend broad availability, not progressively narrow it," he said. 

Adgile’s analysis has repeatedly found the conditions delivering reach efficiently were not necessarily those generating the strongest business outcomes. In one analysis of 10 reach-led campaigns, business outcome delivery varied materially more across placement dimensions than exclusive reach delivery.

Carr said advertisers need a “deduplicated view” of reach and frequency across broadcast and BVOD, comparable delivery data across broadcasters, and privacy-safe measurement connecting exposure with commercial and behavioural outcomes.

“This would allow them to distinguish incremental reach from duplication, manage under- and over-frequency and optimise towards the contexts that improve results, not simply those that are easiest to measure.”

For Lohman, the larger issue was whether advertisers used the transition to improve business results: “Better targeting is not the same thing as better advertising. Automated optimisation is not the same thing as better outcomes.”

He warned an impressive campaign dashboard might reflect optimisation for a publisher’s inventory and yield, rather than the advertiser’s business. “What it usually won’t tell you is whether that optimisation was best for your business or best for the publisher’s inventory and yield. Advertisers need independent measurement, better intelligence and ultimately more control.”

Lohman said the opportunity extended beyond targeting audiences more precisely, “It is that advertisers can understand, in near real time, what is actually working and make decisions based on outcomes rather than delivery metrics.

“That is a much bigger change than replacing the antenna.”

The financial pressure driving the Government review extends beyond campaign performance. Broadcast transmission costs are largely fixed, the paper noted, even as audiences and advertising revenue decline. Broadcasters must also invest in their online services. Close to 90 per cent of terrestrial broadcasting sites are in regional and remote Australia. The paper points to Mildura Digital Television’s closure in 2024 and warned further service reductions could spread beyond larger regional markets if pressures persist.

Some regional commercial broadcasters also lack digital content rights or their own BVOD services under existing rights and affiliation arrangements, limiting their ability to follow audiences online.

Spectrum enters chat

Spectrum nails another financial dimension. UHF spectrum auctions in 2013 and 2017, after television digitisation, generated approximately $3.45 billion for the Commonwealth. The Government is exploring “realising a spectrum dividend”, but has put no price on the potential return.

Commercial broadcasters have put forward a conditional offer to work towards clearing UHF spectrum in the first half of the 2030s if the Commercial Broadcasting Tax is permanently binned. Separately, mobile operators want access to the frequencies for future 6G services and are pushing for reallocation.

No broadcast switch-off date has been set. But the paper makes clear that future spectrum pricing must factor in “optimal television technologies”.

Revenue-based licence fees dating back to 1964 were abolished in 2017 and replaced by charges tied to spectrum use and individual transmitters. In its 2024–25 pre-budget submission, Free TV said the replacement was meant to be an interim measure, initially locked in for five years. 

The current commercial broadcast tax (CBT) is suspended from 9 June 2025 to 8 June 2028, racking up estimated savings of $161.6 million over three years. ACMA said an initial 12-month suspension was extended by another two years. The industry wants that temporary relief made permanent.

Communications Minister, Anika Wells pointed to the two-year extension of the tax suspension as part of the Albanese Government’s ongoing support for the sector, “along with delivering the News Bargaining Incentive, which supports journalists and their important work”.

“We want free-to-air TV to always be available to Australians, however they choose to access it," she said. 

Wells said viewing habits had changed “dramatically”, and the Government was working with the industry to ensure its future sustainability. “This consultation is an important initial step, and I welcome everyone to share their views.”

The consultation was launched at the Uniting a Nation Parliamentary Showcase, alongside Deloitte Access Economics’ report, Towards a More United Nation: The economic and social benefits of commercial television. The report put commercial TV’s contribution to GDP at $2.4 billion in 2024-25, supporting 15,600 full-time equivalent jobs across the economy. It also recorded $15.6 billion invested in Australian content over a decade.

Free TV Australia boss, Bridget Fair said the report put “hard numbers behind something we’ve always known – free television is cultural infrastructure for this country”.

“We thank Minister Wells for starting this important work today, at an event where our Towards a More United Nation: The economic and social benefits of commercial television report demonstrated just how much value free television delivers for Australians,” Fair said.

She said broadcasters were already investing in both broadcast networks and online services, with Government responsible for policy settings and supporting the infrastructure audiences needed. “Free TV will engage fully and constructively with this process, working closely with the telecommunications sector and other stakeholders, because getting the answer right matters enormously – not just to broadcasters, but to the millions of Australians in metro, regional and remote areas, who depend on free, universal access to the TV content that matters to them.”

Free TV Australia will make a detailed submission to the consultation, which closes at 5 pm AEDT on 24 November 2026, and continue engaging with government as the work progresses.

SBS confirmed to Mi3 it would participate, recognising “the importance of all Australians being able to access trusted news, information, entertainment and other content”. “The Government’s future of free-to-air television consultation is an important national discussion,” the broadcaster said.

SCA, Paramount and Nine declined to comment individually when Mi3 approached them, pointing inquiries to Free TV.

What do you think?

Search Mi3 Articles