Harvey Norman and Latitude Finance penalised $55 million for misleading advertising
A 60-month interest-free sales pitch has cost Harvey Norman and Latitude Finance $55 million after a court found their advertising concealed credit card fees and obligations.
The Federal Court has imposed penalties totalling $55 million against Harvey Norman Holdings Ltd and Latitude Finance Australia for misleading conduct and false or misleading representations in advertising. Harvey Norman was fined $35 million, while Latitude Finance Australia was fined $20 million. These penalties are the highest obtained by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) for misleading conduct related to financial products and services.
The misleading advertisements promoted a 60-month interest-free and no deposit payment method for goods at Harvey Norman stores. These advertisements were broadcast across Australia between January 2020 and August 2021. ASIC found that the advertisements failed to disclose that consumers needed to take out a credit card and were liable for monthly account service fees and establishment fees.
ASIC Chair Sarah Court stated, "The substantial penalties and the corrective advertising orders imposed on Harvey Norman and Latitude is a significant outcome for consumers and sends a strong warning to the market about the importance of truthful and transparent advertising." Court further explained, "This case is about integrity in consumer finance marketing. Consumers were entitled to know that this offer involved more than simply paying for their purchase in 60 instalments. The advertising encouraged consumers into an ongoing credit arrangement that carried additional costs and obligations."
Justice O'Bryan criticised both companies for prioritising sales over consumer interests and having inadequate compliance processes. "Today's outcome sends a strong message that businesses must give consumers a clear and accurate picture of the products they are promoting and the costs that come with them," Court added.
Justice O'Bryan remarked, "put sales and their commercial interests above the interests of consumers, and also distorted the markets in which competing goods and finance are offered." He also noted, "the compliance processes of both defendants were wholly inadequate to prevent the contravening conduct." O'Bryan described the situation as "an extraordinary state of affairs" given the scale and sophistication of both defendants, and found it "particularly striking in the case of Harvey Norman."
The court found that "Harvey Norman and Latitude were equally responsible for the contravening advertisements." However, O'Bryan noted, "the defendants have...exhibited a different level of contrition," with "public statements made by Harvey Norman's Chairman show a disregard for the potential harm suffered by consumers from Harvey Norman's misleading conduct." This led to a higher penalty for Harvey Norman, as O'Bryan stated, "A higher penalty is warranted to deter repetition and to motivate Harvey Norman to improve its compliance processes."
Both companies are required to publish corrective advertising on their website home pages for 90 days. ASIC commenced proceedings against the companies on 4 October 2022, alleging breaches of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001. Consumers using the 60-month interest-free payment method could incur at least $537 in fees over the payment period.
Justice Yates found the companies breached the law in October 2024, and their appeals were dismissed by the Full Federal Court in September 2025.
