Skip to main content
Deep Dive 29 May 2025  - 10 min read
AMI CPD: 1  Share  

Tariff turmoil triggers fulfilment scramble as Australian ecoms rush to US hubs: Tales from the front line, and where next

By Sam Shedden - Contributing writer

Ecom economics: Meta’s Will Easton, Profit Peak’s Carla Penn-Kahn, Stefani’s Craig Smethurst, Ecommerce Equation’s Jay Wright, Renovatio’s Vincent Candrawinata, Klaviyo’s Vicky Skipp, Sendle’s Laura Hill and Pattern’s Merline McGrego

Tariffs volatility has seen Australian ecom operators exposed to the US scrambling to reshape distribution with hordes "jumping on planes" for negotiations with third party logistics providers. Others have had containers sitting in the docks, locked in renegotiations with massive US retailers unwilling to absorb costs that make both parties "unviable". Some are now slowing US expansion plans. But there are workarounds for those committed to the US, and ecom veterans suggest Australia's cutthroat, high efficiency environment means the US can provide comparatively easy pickings – despite everything. Mi3 speaks with platforms, retailers, brands and shipping firms on the front line in China and the US, plus consultants that suggest there is high margin opportunity – for those that know where to look.

What you need to know:

  • Tariff volatility has seen a swathe of Australian ecommerce brand execs flying into the US to strike deals with logistics providers and renegotiate with retailers.
  • Ecom brands are doubling down on high value customer segmentation to work out where best to site those logistics operations – and some are finding locational gold nuggets.
  • Others told Mi3 they have paused US expansion, with ships sitting in docks and pricing strategies ricocheting while major retailers operating on thin margins refuse to absorb 100 per cent price increases.
  • Some have been lucky, but are now refocusing marketing on other markets – and there are high margin opportunities to be found.
  • Those committed to the US are making a beeline for Canada, and then paying the tariffs piecemeal by shipped order.
  • But opportunity remains for those less exposed to the highest tariffs – especially because Australian ecommerce economics are so tight that the US will seem comparatively easy – and US competition often far less efficient.
  • Meta’s Will Easton, Profit Peak’s Carla Penn-Kahn, Stefani’s Craig Smethurst, Ecommerce Equation’s Jay Wright, Renovatio’s Vincent Candrawinata, Klaviyo’s Vicky Skipp, Sendle’s Laura Hill and Pattern’s Merline McGregor on what now, and where next.

There’s been not just uncertainty, but panic around tariffs … When it all kicked off, heaps of brands literally jumped on planes to set up third-party logistics.

— Carla Penn-Kahn, Co-Founder, Profit Peak

Heavy messing

Australian ecommerce brands are scrambling to set up warehousing and fulfilment operations in the United States as unpredictable tariff hikes and trade policy changes upend cross-border economics. The rush marks a strategic reset, with firms moving fast to protect margin, maintain delivery speed, and reduce exposure to rising logistics volatility.

That movement is gathering pace, forced by new US rules tightening scrutiny on Chinese-origin goods and winding back the US$800 de minimis threshold, removing duty-free access for many lower-value items. Brands sourcing from Asia and selling into the US are being hit hardest as rising import costs now necessitate changes to fulfilment, sourcing, and inventory planning.

In April, the US imposed a 10 per cent tariff on Australian imports as part of sweeping new “reciprocal” trade measures, but with far harsher duties on China and key Asian hubs. President Trump’s administration is already disrupting Australian ecommerce brands that manufacture or source from the region.

Panic stations

The sudden escalation has left many brands scrambling for cover. Founder of Sydney-based ecommerce advisory firm, Peak Profit, Carla Penn-Kahn, said the last few months have brought a sharp change in posture. Brands that previously resisted the complexity and cashflow burden of overseas logistics are now boarding flights and setting up US hubs in earnest. “There’s been not just uncertainty, but panic around tariffs in the market, and that obviously just impacts margins even more,” she said.

Penn-Kahn has witnessed a sharp escalation in activity. Ecom firms that had been considering overseas expansion suddenly accelerated plans to establish fulfilment capabilities in the US. “When it all kicked off, heaps of brands literally jumped on planes to set up third-party logistics (3PL).”

Meta’s Managing Director for Australia and New Zealand, Will Easton, has observed a similar trend at scale: “We are seeing many of Australia's largest e-commerce brands take proactive steps to establish US-based warehousing operations, driven by the need to mitigate tariff uncertainty,” he said. “While this strategic investment comes with higher upfront costs, it provides a critical layer of protection and predictability – essential for sustaining long-term growth in the highly competitive American market.”

No one can absorb anything. That's the hard thing with this. I guess some of the big brands might have been able to absorb it a bit if they had really high margins. But by and large, if you're dealing with a lot of those retailers – Bed Bath & Beyond in Australia, Home Depot and Walmart [in the US], there isn't a large amount of margin for the suppliers like us, because their retail models are based around providing cheap prices to consumers.

— Craig Smethurst, National Sales Manager, Stefani Australasia

Shipping scramble

One operator witnessing the fallout firsthand is Craig Smethurst, National Sales Manager at Stefani Australasia, whose Barelli Bathrooms and Stefani Water Filtration brands are manufactured in China and exported globally. Speaking to Mi3 from China, Smethurst described extreme pricing volatility and disruption triggered by sudden tariff spikes.

The firm’s US expansion is underpinned by a relationship with retail giant Home Depot, but Smethurst said the company was forced to pause a major US shipment earlier this year as tariffs on Chinese-origin goods escalated sharply.

“When it went to 20 to 40 to 60 to 80 to 100 to 140 per cent tariff, we basically had to put a hold on it for months and a bit,” he said. “That item that you agreed to? It's basically doubled in price.” For retailers like Home Depot, where pricing is fiercely competitive, the margin hit was unworkable.

He said the business is now scrambling to land a shipment in the US during a narrow window while tariff rates have temporarily eased.

“With [the tariffs] dropping down, we're in a bit of a mad rush to try and get this container there within the next 90 days to avoid any risk of it possibly going up.”

That volatility is rippling across Smethurst’s supplier network. During a visit to a supplier in Ningbo, China, he was told that major US retailers like Home Depot and Lowe’s had placed no orders for two and a half months, as rising tariffs rendered low-margin, entry-level goods unviable. In the global macro context, the irony that Ningbo means ‘calm waves’ is not lost on Smethurst.

“No one can absorb anything,” he said because margins are so tight. “That's the hard thing with this. I guess some of the big brands might have been able to absorb it a bit if they had really high margins. But by and large, if you're dealing with a lot of those retailers – Bed Bath & Beyond in Australia, Home Depot, Walmart [in the US], there isn't a large amount of margin for the suppliers like us, because their retail models are based around providing cheap prices to consumers.”

I certainly don’t think it’s doom. We haven’t lost any money ... it just slows down our expansion opportunity. But I definitely have heard stories of people who had a container on the water, and then the retailer wouldn’t pick it up. Basically, it landed in Los Angeles, and the retailer said they weren’t willing to pay for it.

— Craig Smethurst, National Sales Manager, Stefani Australasia

Distribution rethink

While Stefani is using third party logistics providers in the US as it expands, Smethurst said it may ultimately lift its Australian template and build distribution centres. But not right now.

“When you're starting up into a new country, you pretty much don't want to get involved in all that stuff. So at the moment, it’s just a 3PL – and the feedback from them is that at the docks, there are containers sitting there with a lot of companies because they didn’t want to pay the tariffs.”

Smethurst said the firm has been fortunate compared to others.

“The hard thing to come amongst this is the fact that it [tariff rates] was changing from week to week. We would recall something and say, ‘It’s at 30 per cent, this is great, we’ll work with that,’ then we’d redo the pricing – boom – it goes to 50 per cent, then it goes to 80 per cent.

“But because we hadn't officially submitted the pricing to the buyer at this stage, we didn't have to sit there and renegotiate. I know other people where some of the retailers told them ‘We're not accepting a 100 per cent increase – we'll only accept 10 or 20 per cent, which obviously you can't do. No company can afford to absorb that sort of increase,” he suggested.

Smethurst said that fortune was literally pure chance on shipment timing.

“We were probably lucky it happened when it did, before we shipped the goods. So we were able to hit the brakes, for lack of a better term.

"Had we been maybe another six months down the track, and we already had stock there [in the US] and it sold through, and were about to replenish, then we would have really been in trouble,” per Smethurst. “So probably for us, it happened at a good time – before we shipped anything."

Overall, he said the broader business is doing fine, given “it’s practically free trade” between Australia and China. It’s just the US expansion will no longer proceed “two-footed”.

“I certainly don’t think it’s doom. We haven’t lost any money ... it just slows down our expansion opportunity,” said Smethurst.

“But I definitely have heard stories of people who had a container on the water, and then the retailer wouldn’t pick it up. Basically, it landed in Los Angeles, and the retailer said they weren’t willing to pay for it.”

In the long term, he remains optimistic of cracking the US market.

“But if it goes up again, then yeah, we will have to pause.”

If you have aspirations of being a nine-figure revenue brand, Australia is pretty unviable: expensive shipping, 10 per cent GST; it's basically like doing ecommerce on hard mode. The domestic brands overseas often just haven’t grown up in the same conditions we have. They haven’t needed to be as efficient. So when brands do find a market overseas, typically they can really capitalise on it.

— Jay Wright, Founder, Ecommerce Equation

'Not Armageddon'

Despite the turbulence, there’s a growing sense that Australian brands are cutting through in the US. “I think the Aussie brand is having a moment in the US,” per Jay Wright, founder of ecommerce consultancy Ecommerce Equation. With interest in clean ingredients, lifestyle positioning and independent labels, several operators are finding fresh opportunity even as costs and tariffs ricochet.

“It's probably around trend and vibe … maybe being on trend, a casual or certain aesthetic that is on point at the moment. You’re seeing it manifest in a lot of different ways. Australian coffee houses are having a moment over there, so it's not just in products and fashion and apparel. It's also from a general lifestyle perspective. Aussie culture is sort of exporting well at the moment.”

Tariffs uncertainty aside, Wright suggests Australian ecommerce business may the US trading environment much less cutthroat than their local turf.

“If you have aspirations of being a nine-figure revenue brand, Australia is pretty unviable. We have relatively expensive shipping. We have 10 per cent GST … it's basically like doing ecommerce on hard mode. The US economy is 75 per cent consumption – ours is 50 per cent. They have 20 times the amount of people, and they each spend 50 per cent more than the Australian consumer. The average sales tax is 4 per cent instead of 10 per cent. Shipping is cheaper. There’s a much more propensity to purchase online,” he said.

“So as an Australian brand we are steeled in very hard conditions and as a result, we all focus a lot on efficiencies, really dialling in our unit economics and pushing up our revenue per visitor and average order value and conversion rate. We’re extremely efficient machines to survive. So I think that translates very well when you go overseas, because the domestic brands overseas … they often just haven’t grown up in the same conditions we have. They haven’t needed to be as efficient. So when brands do find a market overseas, typically they can really capitalise on it.”

Wright suggested while perhaps 30 per cent of Australian ecom firms will be feeling the pain, the bulk are less affected.

“The media makes it out like this is Armageddon. But there's, one quadrant, which is brands that have a high percentage of their revenue to the US, that also manufacture in China … that's most impacted by the tariffs.”

[Ecom firms] can bulk send product to a free trade zone like Canada and when an order comes through [from the US], they'll send that order to the customer, and they pay the tariff order by order. Whereas, if you start a 3PL in the US, you still have to pay the tariff at the time of import. From a cash flow perspective, that can be quite a heavy burden. So I think that's probably the most common thing [we’re seeing].”

— Jay Wright, Founder, Ecommerce Equation

Canada calling

Those perhaps most exposed include apparel brands, where much of the manufacturing is China-based. Many firms would ship product from China to an Australian centralised warehouse, he said, and then distribute globally from there, particularly to the US.

“The unit economics still made sense. It was expensive shipping, but the strength of the US dollar meant that there was a little bit of an arbitrage of purchasing power parity, where you could basically charge more in Australian dollar terms for the same goods, and that would somewhat subsidise the shipping. But the tariff is now unviable, because if you're getting hit with a 40, 45 per cent tariff, once the de minimis [duty] rolls off, then it's just completely non-viable. You can't you can't recover that with pricing. You'll just be completely uncompetitive in the market.”

Hence brands setting up third party logistics operations in free trade zones, “in Canada in particular,” said Wright.

“What that means is they can bulk send product to a free trade zone like Canada, and then when they import, when an order comes through, they'll send that order to the customer, and they pay the tariff order by order.

"Whereas, if you start a 3PL in the US, you still have to pay the tariff just on the cost of goods at the time of import. Just from a cash flow perspective, that can be quite a heavy burden. So it seems like there is, for those people that are heavily impacted, a bit of a move to going from a single warehouse solution in Australia to moving the North American orders to a dedicated third-party logistics provider,” he said.

“We see a lot of interest in these free trade zones, so they don't have to wear the whole tariff cost at the time they import. They can just pay it order by order as things get shipped to the US.

“So I think that's probably the most common thing. There's definitely a lot of interest in seeking out other manufacturing partners. But it's not that easy.”

Very quickly, we pivoted ... we are holding [on] to two of our hero products ... because juggling two products while walking the tightrope is so much easier than juggling many.

— Dr Vincent Candrawinata, Founder, Renovatio

‘Hidden costs'

Renovatio, a science-led nutraceutical brand founded by Dr Vincent Candrawinata, would likely agree with Wright's view.

The firm has shelved immediate plans to manufacture in the United States due to escalating uncertainty and cost pressures. While the business had long aimed to expand US operations through local application manufacturing, Candrawinata said, “It’s not something we can just turn on next week. It’s still something that we need to consider very, very carefully ... the biggest issue we are facing ... is the uncertainty.”

Instead, the health and wellness brand – which specialises in antioxidant products derived from Australian apples – is narrowing its focus to fewer products while continuing to operate from Australia. “Very quickly, we pivoted ... we are holding [on] to two of our hero products ... because juggling two products while walking the tightrope is so much easier than juggling many,” he said.

The move is partly in response to cost blowouts in shipping and freight. “The increase in cost in terms of logistics, handling, and managing and storing the product has gone substantially higher compared to the actual tariff itself,” Candrawinata said. “There are a lot of hidden costs behind it that are caused by the tariff, that are not actually tariffs.”

Retention remapped

As cost pressures mount and international expansion plans become more complex, many brands are shifting from growth-at-all-costs to smarter customer retention and sharper profit metrics. Klaviyo’s Asia Pacific Director, Vicky Skipp, said brands are ramping data-driven segmentation and operational efficiency to protect margin:

“Who are my buyers, which suburbs are they in, what channels are they buying on – and they’re being much more efficient in how they personalise messaging and tailor messaging,” she said. “It tells them about how they buy, what they buy, when they buy – then also leads to retention.”

She said fashion brand Meshki also is using that kind of data to inform its fulfilment setup in the US: After identifying a dense cluster of high-value customers on the East Coast, it opted to establish a 3PL warehouse in New Jersey over California.

It’s just a little bit more complex now that the requirements to enter the US have increased ... There are just more things that people need to be mindful of in terms of where your product is manufactured ... Faster moving goods will be feeling the pinch.

— Laura Hill, Managing Director, Sendle

State of origin

While some larger brands are fast-tracking US fulfilment and reassessing markets, smaller players are grappling with added complexity, according to shipping carrier Sendle’s Managing Director, Laura Hill.

“It’s just a little bit more complex now that the requirements to enter the US have increased ... There are just more things that people need to be mindful of in terms of where your product is manufactured,” she said.

That includes verifying origin with confidence. “Really understanding your supply chain aspect – so you can say this is produced in X or Y country ... there's a lot more information that a business needs to supply.”

The removal of the de minimis duty threshold has likewise introduced a fresh hurdle for ecommerce operators: “That’s gone, so the taxes apply on anything now,” Hill explained. She noted that fast-moving consumer categories like fashion are particularly exposed. “I do think it’s those faster moving goods ... that will be feeling the pinch.”

Geographic reset

Hence some Australian brands now shelving US expansion plans and shifting their sights to alternative markets in mainland Europe and UK to diversify revenue and reduce dependency on the US.

But Ecommerce Equation’s Jay Wright reckons that has always been the case for Australian ecoms – at least seasonally - and that there are other high value markets to be unearthed by those who know where to look.

“Every winter it hits March or April, and if you sell swimwear or beach towels or hammocks or anything that is seasonal, and you are an Australian or a New Zealand brand, most of those guys start to look to the northern hemisphere, otherwise it's just a long and slow winter," he said.

“We've long been proponents for not fixating on the US and taking more of a worldwide approach – where we'll use particularly Meta's algorithm to go and find people for products worldwide. Then we narrow in on the most performative countries. Often the US is definitely in there, but there's a bunch of rich people all over the world – in Singapore, Hong Kong, UAE, Qatar, places you would never really think to target, Europe as well.”

Hence brands that are finding US tariffs volatility unviable “may be just shifting a little bit more of their focus to other regions that they might be trading in anyway”, said Wright. “Those that are nimble and don't have [highly] established US business yet, are probably shifting advertising focus a little bit out of that region.”

Making sure that your product is in the most efficient classification… will make a difference. It’s one of the more tactical levers brands can pull in the current environment. But my advice to brands is both from a manufacturing point of view and from a logistics perspective – look at de-risking and diversification.

— Merline McGregor, Managing Director ANZ, Pattern

Lasting damage?

Merline McGregor, Managing Director ANZ at ecom accelerator Pattern, agreed  a shift in emphasis is underway, with strategic conversations among her clients ramping up.

“The tariffs have just sparked more of an unease around the stability of the economy and consumer appetite,” she said. “Brands are potentially starting to look at other regions and other markets as their first priority, rather than necessarily putting all of their eggs into one basket.”

While some are reprioritising non-US markets, others committed to the US are re-examining fulfilment structures to manage margin pressure. That includes more deliberate use of tariff classification rules. “Making sure that your product is in the most efficient classification… will make a difference,” said McGregor. “It’s one of the more tactical levers brands can pull in the current environment.”

Shifting freight methods is another consideration. “Air freight is expensive. Sea freight not as expensive,” she said. “When you used to get something in two weeks, and now you’re going to wait 67 or 68 days by boat – it changes the way we do things.”

McGregor said brands that best weather the storm will be those that spread their bets and prioritise operational agility.

“My advice to brands is both from a manufacturing point of view and from a logistics perspective – look at de-risking and diversification,” she said.

“This has been a wake-up call … that the world can change overnight.”

What do you think?

Search Mi3 Articles