Finding a strong CMO voice
Those are just some of reflections CMO Awards judges had after reading the submissions from our second-year CMOs of the Year entries. And off the back of these, I shared with Gala Awards attendees my own summation of how I believe marketing leaders are truly gaining their ‘VOICE’ inside organisations and realising their growth ambitions.
V is for velocity: Almost every submission talked to this imperative of picking up the pace – whether it was velocity in decision making, in campaign and content execution or operating rhythms. Yes it’s the year of the horse – and boy are we galloping. There’s more content, more channels, more campaign executions, more communication, more choices. With AI, what we’re going to have to be careful of is that we don’t just do more, faster, because the tools enable us to. Crap in is still crap out, broken process is still broken process, and a lack of marketing discipline or skill isn’t going to be solved by just throwing agents at the task.
I do think we’re at an inflection point of AI where the question that needs to be put first is this: WHY are we doing it?
Take Accenture Australia’s CMO Carrie Smith. She told us on our recent CMO Awards AI capability podcast that the team looked at the marketing discipline first to understand where the bottlenecks are, the bits they were not doing well, and where more deeper data crunching could be leveraged to do things better. The first port of call became briefing, sorting out a better way for local and global teams to understand the nuance of markets, strategy, and brief it in better.
O is for opportunity: The modus operandi for the best marketers is seeking opportunity to capitalise on – whether that’s an opportunity to influence, to build cross functional connections, to better connect to peers and to customers, and the opportunities in the data to realise and action. But this isn’t just a scattergun approach. There’s deliberate choices being made here and we can point to many examples where the opportunity is to try to stop stretching budget and focus dollars to get a higher return.
I is for incrementality: Disruptive growth isn’t always going to be possible, but I’m using incrementality here to also describe how marketers are looking to ensure they’re articulating lift – ultimately in sales – with things they’ve done that go beyond what might have happened if they hadn’t bothered. We had many people looking to find gains – more discerning decision making on media spends for outsized returns is one. Marketing is about upping the ROI, overindexing when you can, building the case for investment into existing products, extending to new distribution channels, better targeting segments and driving personalisation for a better return.
C is for clarity: Most capability building and restructuring actively comes down to this. Clarity in what the brand means, what teams do, how they integrate and hand off, who’s accountable, resource concentration, what the outcome is, and to shift teams from execution into strategy-led functions.
But it’s also clarity around the rationale for marketing. As one judge pointed out, almost universally, candidates described transforming marketing from a support or cost-centre function into a primary driver of revenue, profit, and enterprise value. This has required structural, cultural, and strategic reinvention.
E is for effectiveness: This is the one marketers recognise is critical to their impact, tenure and business standing. We have a lot of examples of efficiency gains – most of the time it’s manifesting as cost or media effectiveness.
The definition of effectiveness is “the degree to which actions produce determined results and how well a goal is achieved”. The best marketers make great cases for what they’re doing along these lines.
But I’d argue we need to get to commercial effectiveness – that’s the distinction. Unit economics, gross profit, business language and needs. It comes back to this.