Media agency sector shutdown: good start, more effectiveness for 2020 agenda?
The buzz was good, the turnout strong, EQ debates high and industry big guns from IAG's Brent Smart to Seven's James Warburton and Dentsu's Henry Tajer threw some curveballs. So let's talk more about impact and effectiveness for MFA Ex 2020
Last week was a big statement by media agencies to shake themselves up. The industry all but shut itself down for a day and sent its people to a town hall gathering for lashings of introspection, a bit of strategy, a swig of effectiveness and a touch of collective punch.
The fodder was diverse and even by day's end, debate from the floor to a panel of agency CEOs was robust, if a splash too feisty for some.
At their core, media agencies and journalism are similar beasts. Both are gatekeepers - one for information and content, the other for how billions of advertising dollars are allocated to fund that content and information. And both sectors have historically carried historical swagger because of that gatekeeper status. But now both are under enormous commercial pressure.
Journalism, though, has been hacked harder than media agencies so far - 30 per cent of the industry has gone in the past decade, according to Bloomberg Media CEO, Justin Smith. But a similar horizon faces media agencies as disintermediation from emerging alternatives, automation and unsustainable remuneration structures continue to bite.
Perhaps belatedly, media agencies as a collective last week started to do something about it. The intent was part inspiration and partly to get smarter, faster, more open.
MFA EX was a good start although there remains plenty of baggage for the sector to surface. We saw that in a number of sessions last week where workplace culture, mental health, general wellbeing and high employee churn rates were widely discussed.
With so much discussion orbiting these important, softer, industry wellbeing issues, here's a thought: UnLtd's recent mental health survey across the industry shows people in media and advertising are 20 per cent more likely to show symptoms of depression than the national average. They're also 29 per cent more likely to show symptoms of anxiety.
If the sector is bustling with early and heavy users of technology and social media, which it is, might there be a causal link or correlation to the science which keeps suggesting social media is causing unprecedented levels of angst, depression and self-harm amongst younger people? It's worth some genuine - and possibly uncomfortable - discussion. But we digress. Or at least attempt to finish on a high note.
It was noted on a number of occasions across the MFA EX event that the industry can get to glum quite well. Dentsu's CEO Henry Tajer made a quip on the final panel that there was possibly only three people at MFA EX last week that were talking positively about the industry, its prospects, output and effectiveness.
The latter is a valid point. Through the day there were flashes of smart, effective work and thinking on show and in Europe and the US there is rising interest around reframing media as a growth driver for business, not just a cost lever. But it requires a shift in mindset and a new search for better evidence that could partly shape next year's MFA EX, assuming it returns (and it should). The MFA board and executive are onto something.
Finally, a parting word on a discussion I was involved in with Mumbrella's Tim Burrowes on whether trade media is friend or foe to the industry. Apparently some thought there were strong points made all round but no solution reached.
For the record, a 20-minute discussion ain't going to solve what is a peculiar and troubling characteristic of the Australia trade media, versus its international peers. That is, we are at advanced levels of nark and negativity and low levels of considered, intelligent industry coverage and debate on important trends, issues and developments.
A transformed industry needs a different kind of industry conversation. The solution lies partly in creating an industry-wide desire for more considered yet still challenging conversations. Unrealistic? Probably. But like politics, we get who we vote for.
To MFA EX 2020 and beyond.
2021’s most valuable brand-owned media channel might surprise you (hint: it’s not social or the web)
The most valuable media channel of 2021 that brands own and control themselves has an average click-through rate around 100 times higher than most ads. It’s not a page on the latest social media platform, a digital screen network, or a brand activation zone. It’s bigger than Facebook, trusted, brand-safe and personalised. But marketers need to respect – and better leverage - its value. Because hot channels rarely equate to valuable channels, says Sonder's Jonathan Hopkins.